Civil Rights Cases - Milestone Documents

Civil Rights Cases

( 1883 ) Commentary by R. Owen Williams, Yale University, and Lisa Paddock, Independent Scholar, Cape May County, New Jersey
  • “If it is supposable that the States may deprive persons of life, liberty, and property without due process of law (and the amendment itself does suppose this), why should not Congress proceed at once to prescribe due process of law for the protection of every one of these fundamental rights, in every possible case, as well as to prescribe equal privileges in inns, public conveyances, and theatres? … The assumption is certainly unsound. ” - Joseph P. Bradley: Majority Opinion
  • “It would be running the slavery argument into the ground to make it apply to every act of discrimination which a person may see fit to make as to guests he will entertain, or as to the people he will take into his coach or cab or car, or admit to his concert or theatre, or deal with in other matters of intercourse or business.” - Joseph P. Bradley: Majority Opinion
  • “That there are burdens and disabilities which constitute badges of slavery and servitude, and that the express power delegated to congress to enforce, by appropriate legislation, the thirteenth amendment, may be exerted by legislation of a direct and primary character, for the eradication, not simply of the institution, but of its badges and incidents, are propositions which ought to be deemed indisputable.” - John Marshall Harlan: Dissent
  • “It is, I submit, scarcely just to say that the colored race has been the special favorite of the laws. What the nation, through congress, has sought to accomplish in reference to that race is, what had already been done in every state in the Union for the white race, to secure and protect rights belonging to them as freemen and citizens; nothing more. The one underlying purpose of congressional legislation has been to enable the black race to take the rank of mere citizens. The difficulty has been to compel a recognition of their legal right to take that rank, and to secure the enjoyment of privileges belonging, under the law, to them as a component part of the people for whose welfare and happiness government is ordained.” - John Marshall Harlan: Dissent
Image for: Civil Rights Cases

Joseph P. Bradley (Library of Congress)

View Full Size

Related Docs